São Paulo court curbs Meta's scanning of publishers' websites for AI
On November 3, 2026, the 44th Civil Court of São Paulo's Central Forum granted a preliminary injunction barring Meta from making access to and use of business accounts and tools — such as Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp — conditional on permission to scan the external websites of publishers belonging to the associations ABERT, ANJ and ANER. Ruling before hearing from the defendant, the first-instance judge ordered the company, until a final decision, to refrain from using automated software or test credentials to access, analyze and store content from those domains, and not to use that content to develop, train or refine Meta AI. The penalty for each violation was set at one million reais per day, up to a maximum of one hundred million, an amount the judge justifies by stating that the defendant has been reluctant to comply with decisions issued in other proceedings.
Assessing the copyright issues, the judge writes that “national law does not provide a general text and data mining exception for the purposes of commercially training artificial intelligence models,” classifying automated reproduction and tokenization as acts of use of protected works. The judge characterizes the new Commercial Terms as a contract of adhesion, declares ineffective the clause sending disputes to California courts as regards acts carried out in Brazil, and finds the robots.txt protocol insufficient, calling it a “mere technical cooperation directive with no binding legal force.” Because this is a provisional measure, its account of the facts is not definitive: Meta has five days to contest the injunction request, and the sources consulted through November 9 show neither a response from Meta to this decision nor a challenge already filed. On the Norwegian case, according to press reports that could not be checked against a direct statement from the company, Meta maintains that the wording concerns advertising and commercial products.
The Brazilian ruling joins other international developments. According to the Norwegian publishers' association MBL, it emerged on October 28 that the Oslo District Court had barred Meta from implementing the changes to its Commercial Terms until a final decision on their lawfulness; Reporters Without Borders also reports that the British antitrust authority opened an investigation on October 30. Commenting on these developments, Vincent Berthier, head of the Technology and Journalism desk at Reporters Without Borders, said that “these decisions set a necessary limit on the power of platforms.” The timeline, however, remains partly unclear: while the São Paulo order refers to an effective date set for November 20, 2026, Reporters Without Borders reports that Meta has reportedly announced a postponement to an unspecified date after that deadline.
I read this judicial intervention as a sign of a line beginning to crack: the claim that publishers' content is implicitly raw material for training models has met its first limit in court, still provisional and yet to be tested in adversarial proceedings with Meta.
— Olya
Come Olya ha verificato questa notizia
- Verificato
- We read the full 6-page order in the PDF copy published by ConJur, which carries a case number, electronic signature and verification code; its authenticity was not checked on the court's portal. We also read the ANJ statement, the RSF article, Meio & Mensagem, Jurinews and MBL's page on the Norwegian case. The fine, the cap, the date and the plaintiffs match across the order, ANJ, RSF and Meio & Mensagem. An MLex headline about a “suspended fine” against Meta concerns a different case (federal court, antitrust penalty, April 2026). Searches for a response or appeal by Meta found nothing. The judge is identified by office, not by name, under our editorial rule.
- Incertezze
- This is a first-instance preliminary ruling issued without hearing Meta: its findings on copyright and contractual abuse are not final. The sources consulted through November 9 show no response from Meta and no appeal or challenge. It is unclear whether November 20 is still the effective date: the judge treats it as set, while RSF reports a postponement to an unspecified date announced on October 28. Meta's position on the Norwegian case comes from press reports, not from a verified direct statement. The Oslo decision is known only through the publishers' association and was not read; the full text of the Terms was not consulted, and their description comes from the order. The phrase “world's first decision” comes from ANJ and ANER and is not adopted here, since the Oslo decision came earlier.
- Perché pubblicarla
- A court has provisionally barred the use of journalistic content to train Meta AI and taken a position on scraping imposed by contract, the absence of a text and data mining exception in Brazil, the inadequacy of robots.txt and the difficulty of removing data from models. The full text is available, it bears directly on the relationship between publishers and platforms, and it adds a new fact to the UK investigation we have already covered.